Managing Overthinking (HBR Review): Tools for Entrepreneurs to Stop Spinning

There’s a version of burnout no one talks about.

Not the kind where you collapse from too many hours. Not the impressive overwork that looks good on Instagram. I'm talking about the quiet, invisible kind—the mental quicksand where your brain runs loops at 2am, replaying that one decision you still haven’t made. Or worse, the moment you crushed it—but instead of celebrating, you're dissecting how it could've been better. That's overthinking. And it's silently draining your edge.

I didn’t realize how much it was costing me until I read Managing Overthinking from Harvard Business Review's Emotional Intelligence series. This isn’t a book about doing more. It's about thinking clearer—so you can actually do what matters.

While entrepreneurs will find this book transformative, anyone juggling high-stakes decisions can benefit from its tools.

Overthinking Isn’t Just a Quirk—It’s a Performance Killer

Entrepreneurs are natural overthinkers. We have to be strategic, aware of risk. But when analysis turns into paralysis, we don’t just lose time—we lose opportunities and momentum.

This book slices through the fog with a clarity that made me say out loud, "Oh damn, that's me."

It breaks overthinking into three types:

Quick Reference: Three Types of Overthinking

  • Rumination — Past-focused guilt loops

  • Future Tripping — Anxiety about what could go wrong

  • Overanalyzing — Digging too deep, losing sight of action

Knowing which one you're trapped in changes how you escape it.

What Hit Me: The Invisible Energy Leak

Some days you feel wiped out but haven’t done much. That’s mental energy burn.

Rumination is the culprit more often than not. Like a director recutting a movie that already premiered, you're stuck editing the past.

The book offers clear, no-fluff tactics:

  • Schedule "worry time" to contain spirals

  • Use visualization (like releasing a mental balloon)

  • Anchor in the present task when looping starts

These are subtle, but powerful shifts. Overthinking isn’t a mindset issue. It’s a habit loop.

A Personal Example: The Funnel That Almost Didn't Launch

A few months ago, I was about to launch a new product. The funnel was 90% done. Yet I couldn’t hit publish.

Every time I opened the dashboard, I found another tweak. A slightly better CTA. A pixel off. Another round of "research." Meanwhile, the team waited.

Reading this book helped me name what was happening: I wasn’t aiming for excellence. I was avoiding judgment.

Chapter 1 introduced a game-changer: satisficing.

Instead of perfect, aim for good enough that gets the job done.

I picked three criteria. Set a 48-hour launch clock. Pulled the trigger.

Revenue rolled in. And yes—I still saw things I’d change. But perfectionism? That was just overthinking in a tux.

Battle-Tested Tools You’ll Actually Use

This book isn’t about breathing exercises or yoga mantras. It’s full of real-world mental frameworks:

  • Temporal distancing – Zoom out: how will this feel in 5 years?

  • Cognitive defusion – See thoughts as patterns, not gospel

  • Name-based self-talk – "Alright, Jamie, what’s really happening here?"

  • Invisible support – Help your team quietly, without triggering pride or defensiveness

These aren’t theory. These are ready-to-use workplace moves.

Decision Fatigue Is Real—Here’s the Antidote

The book also hits hard on deliberation fatigue. When everything feels like it needs a spreadsheet and a pros/cons list, you stall out.

Two insights changed how I operate:

  1. Don’t aim to make the right decision. Aim to make the decision right.

  2. Trust your gut—but train it.

One CEO flips a coin not to choose, but to gauge his emotional response. Brilliant micro-check.

Why This Book Matters (Especially for Entrepreneurs)

  • We lead while in motion. Overthinking stalls us.

  • We self-assess without a scoreboard. It’s draining.

  • We chase clarity. Overthinking gives us fake clarity.

  • We chase perfect. But perfect delays progress.

This book offers simple, daily-level tools to reroute your brain—without therapy, retreats, or radical lifestyle change.

“Satisficing,” introduced in Chapter 1, alone helped me cut my launch cycle in half.

Favorite Chapter: When to Stop Deliberating and Just Decide

Chapter 7 is a masterclass in decision-making.

Key tools:

  • Meta-decision analysis: Decide how to decide (based on importance, urgency, repeatability)

  • Option buying: Start small instead of committing everything upfront

  • Decision clock: Set a deadline to avoid spinning endlessly

These tools helped me shave a hiring cycle from 4 weeks to 7 days.

Limitations? A Few.

While this book nails overthinking at work, it’s light on deeper clinical issues. If you're navigating anxiety or trauma-rooted thought patterns, you may want something more therapeutic.

Also, its examples are mostly professional. Those seeking more focus on relationships or parenting may need to stretch the application.

Final Word (and Action Step)

You can’t scale a business if you can’t scale your thinking.

Managing Overthinking doesn’t just talk mindset—it gives you a manual.

If you’re mentally jammed, caught in choice loops, or secretly self-sabotaging behind a polished facade—read this.

Buy the book. Apply one idea. Watch momentum return.

FAQs

Q: Who is this book for?
Entrepreneurs, managers, creatives—anyone who overthinks under pressure.

Q: Is it more theory or action?
Heavy on action. It breaks down thought patterns and gives ready-to-apply tools.

Q: Do I need to read the whole Emotional Intelligence series?
Nope. This stands alone, though fans of EQ topics may want more from the series.

Q: Can it help with chronic anxiety or clinical issues?
It’s great for workplace-level overthinking, but not a substitute for therapy.

Q: Where can I buy it?
Amazon, most major booksellers or joining audible.

Inscrivez-vous à notre newsletter